Double Standard: Iraq or Afghanistan?
Published on 30 June 2004
President of the American Institute of Archaeology warns the US not to forget the rich heritage of Aghanistan
Since the looting of the Iraq National Museum in Baghdad and the burning of the city’s libraries last spring, major worldwide efforts have focused on rebuilding Iraq’s cultural institutions, conserving damaged artifacts, and training guards to prevent looting of archaeological sites. Meanwhile, what has happened to archaeology in Afghanistan? The Taliban’s destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas three years ago (see www.archaeology.org/afghanistan) drew international attention and calls for action, but since then Afghanistan has received nothing like the assistance in rebuilding its archaeological and cultural heritage that Iraq has in a much shorter time.
Up to now, for example, the U.S. government has contributed about $100,000 for the reconstruction of the Kabul Museum’s roof but has done little else. UNESCO and the governments of France, Japan, and Germany have helped to a somewhat greater extent. Greece’s pledge of $300,000 for the museum has not yet materialized. One possible reason for this neglect is the relative unfamiliarity to westerners of Afghanistan’s heritage in contrast to that of ancient Mesopotamia (Iraq). Many Americans have heard of the Fertile Crescent, the Ziggurat at Ur, the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, and Nebucchadnezzar, king of Babylonia, but how many can name even one ancient site or historical figure associated with Afghanistan?
Afghanistan’s needs, along with Iraq’s, were highlighted at the January 2004 annual meeting of the Archaeological Institute of America (AIA) in San Francisco. Speaking there, Abdul Wasey Feroozi, director of the National Archaeological Institute in Kabul, outlined the damage done in his country: "The catastrophe of war annihilated seventy years of our hard work and accomplishments. In the period from 1992 to 1994...over 70 percent of the Kabul National Museum was burned and damaged and 100 percent of the objects were stolen or vandalized. Illegal excavations and extensive clandestine digging started at most historical sites, and thousands of valuable objects were transported to other countries, notably through Pakistan, to the international markets." (See the AIA website, www.archaeological.org, for Feroozi’s complete presentation.)
In a spirit of hope, distinguished Afghan archaeologist Zemaryalai Tarzi, president of the Association for the Protection of Afghan Archaeology (APAA) and director of the French Archaeological Mission for field investigations in Bamiyan, has resumed excavations there, though the site is strewn with land mines and looting continues through much of the country. "How can one respect a nation in the present if one does not respect its past?" says Tarzi. Through the APAA (www.apaa.info), he plans to create an inventory of stolen objects and raise international awareness about the irreparable losses to Afghan archaeological heritage. Afghanistan’s rich cultural heritage must not be forgotten. We at the AIA urge that the U.S., other governments, and private donors put as much money and effort into Afghanistan as they do into Iraq--to safeguard sites, rebuild museums, and train a new generation of archaeologists, conservators, and museum personnel. To do less would be shameful.
Back to previous page