Culture: the cry of men in face of their destiny
Published on 1 October 2010
Pledged funds were generous sums but when divided between Haiti's 10 million inhabitants they added up to only a small per capita figure per year
Haiti needs "more, better, different" assistance from the world, including significant private investment, if it is to have any hope of developing beyond the humanitarian crisis caused by the Jan. 12 earthquake, the country's prime minister said on Thursday.
Jean-Max Bellerive told Reuters that aid pledged so far by foreign governments and institutions would not be enough to meet the enormous challenges facing the crippled Caribbean state after the catastrophic natural disaster that killed up to 300,000 people and made some 1.3 million more homeless.
"I need more, I need better and I need it differently," he said in a frank interview in which he thanked the world for its solidarity, while making clear that much more funding, both public and private, and greatly improved coordination of its delivery, was needed to help Haiti "build back better."
"'Build back better' is tied to those three criteria. We have the plan, but now we need the means," Bellerive said, adding that his small, quake-ravaged country, already one of the poorest states in the world, would be a critical test case of the real effectiveness of international aid.
At a meeting in New York in March, Bellerive said donors pledged $11 billion - more than originally announced -- for Haiti's post-quake reconstruction over 10 years, of which $5.3 billion was to be delivered over 2010-2011.
But he said many aid pledges factored in debt forgiveness or money already spent on Haiti's humanitarian emergency.
He added the pledged funds were generous sums but when divided between Haiti's 10 million inhabitants they added up to only a small per capita figure per year in the face of the daunting panoply of needs in education, health, infrastructure and agriculture development being confronted by the country.
Without a major new influx of foreign private investment -- the "different" assistance Bellerive was seeking -- the government and its relief partners risked using up the currently pledged funds just to cover the "humanitarian dramas" posed by having 1.3 million homeless quake survivors living in fragile tent camps across Port-au-Prince, he said.
Clearing the rubble from the quake alone would cost an estimated $1.2 billion, Bellerive said. He added that providing decent housing to each of the total 2 million quake homeless and chronically destitute could itself cost $10 billion - nearly the total being pledged by the international community for the full-blown national recovery and development program.
Unless this funds shortfall was addressed and a major influx of investment came, "I will have Haiti in the same situation, without food ... without nothing and without any opportunity to create development," Bellerive said.
"WE NEED ALL THE HELP WE CAN GET"
He appealed for better coordination of aid, to take into account the government's priorities. "How I am going to get that money? What will be the channels you are going to use to send it? You have $50 million in Haiti, is it budget support, to finance a program, or going through an NGO?" he said.
Bellerive repeated an oft-cited official complaint that hundreds of foreign NGOs operate in Haiti with no regard or accountability to the government.
"We need NGOs in Haiti, but we need NGOs that are working with the government, under the government plan ... it's the way it's done that has to be improved, more coordination ... to avoid chaos, " he added.
Bellerive also advocated "more aggressive diplomacy" by Haiti to widen its pool of donors. "We have a group of traditional donors in Haiti and I don't believe they can do a lot more than what they are doing now," he said.
He suggested new partners could include Arab countries, Asian countries like China, but also more engagement from northern European countries like Sweden and Britain.
"I am not going to make politics with the development of Haiti. We need all the help that we can get," he said.
The prime minister said Haiti, despite its poverty and the devastating earthquake, was a small nation with no ethnic wars or major health epidemics. "If the whole international community cannot solve the problem, along with the Haitians ... it raises a lot of questions over the effectiveness and utility of cooperation and international aid," he added.
"We are solvable," Bellerive said. (Additional reporting by Guy Delva; Editing by Doina Chiacu)
13 June 2013
Due to heavy workload
20 February 2013
We emptied Syria's museums
19 February 2013
The ancient manuscripts of Timbuktu are a door into Africa's golden age. We must not let this crisis threaten their survival
These manuscripts are our identity
Mosaics depicting scenes from Homer?s epic poem The Odyssey.
18 February 2013
Press, reigime and propaganda
International Conference on Protection of Cultural Property in Asia